The One and Only Unofficial Website for  Ilkeston Town Football Club

 1945-2005

 WhiteBallProject Reports January 2005
News Reports Dear Diary Forum Stats Archive Links Home

 

WHITBY WIN BRUISING BATTLE

22nd January  2005  UniBond League Cup

 

Whitby Town 

3 - 1

Ilkeston Town 

McTiernan 2 pen 80

Johnson 30   

 

Att 269

Jervis 6

Campbell

Atkinson

Williams

Farthing

Linighan

Nicholson

McTiernan

Scaife

Johnson

Gildea L

Bishop

 

Robinson

Ormerod

Gildea A

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

subs

12

14

15

Turner

Clifford

Lucas

Lever

Gaunt

Walshe

Smith

Holmes

Goddard

Jemson

Jervis

 

Davies

Copnell for Lucas 35 mins 

Knowles

 

Whitby go 1-0 up from the spot  Jemson gets stuck in

 

Ilkeston Town made the long journey north to Whitby for their first ever game against the Unibond League Premier Division promotion hopefuls. Manager Phil Stant had the luxury of picking the same team that won impressively at Warrington last week. That meant there was no place for top scorer Ryan Hindley back after his dramatic vacation in the far east.

 

The Robins made the worst possible start to the game when Mark Clifford was judged to have handled in the box after only two minutes. David McTiernan stepped up and confidently stroked the ball past Ross Turner. Ilkeston's response to this setback was impressive and within four minutes they had equalised when Nigel Jemson's clever header set up David Jervis to score with a sweet volley.

 

Whitby however were not willing to sit back and let the Robins take control of the game and they dominated much of the first half forcing Ross Turner into making a number of fine saves. After 30 minutes they eventually broke the Robins rearguard when Steve Johnson raced clear and confidently slotted the ball past Turner. Whitby then proceeded to miss some very good chances and had to be content with a slender 2-1 lead at half time.

 

After the break Ilkeston had their best spell of the game and forced Whitby back into their own half. Unfortunately their efforts to get back into the game were hampered by a number of bad tempered flare ups. Jemson was booked after 53 minutes and then two Whitby players were booked in quick succession. In between the behavioral problems Jemson got in a good header at goal. On 57 minutes Stuart Copnell was booked for an over enthusiastic challenge and then Gareth Homes was unfortunately booked after being on the end of some very ugly challenges.

 

Whitby weathered the Ilkeston pressure and came back into the game strongly and should have done better with two chances from headers. Ilkeston's hopes of getting anything out of the game almost completely disappeared after 74 minutes when Liam Walshe was sent off. Referee Mr Salt who had little control over proceedings was unable to get the Whitby back ten yards at a free kick. To stop them encroaching Walshe stood in front of the wall. He appeared to have been pushed in the back but retaliated with his elbow. McTiernan went down dramatically and Walsh was shown the red card. The travelling Ilkeston support were livid at the perceived injustice and it looked for a while that the game might turn very ugly.

 

Whitby calmed things down however with ten minutes to go when the unpopular McTiernan got on the end of a low right wing cross to give the home side an unassailable two goal lead.

 

WhiteBallProject Man of the Match - Gareth Holmes (pictured below) Fought and battled the whole game and was the subject of some very special attention from the Whitby players.

 

Post Mortem

 

The unpleasant challenges, the indifferent refereeing and ugly scenes at the end of the game overshadowed much of the football in this game. Ilkeston Town were beaten by a better team who passed the ball better and took their chances with clinical efficiency. Gareth Holmes apart too many of the Robin's players were out of sorts and allowed themselves to be wound up by Mr Salt's weak refereeing

 

Ilkeston had a good spell just after the break but started a lack of discipline when they started to get involved in some very nasty challenges. Both teams were guilty of over aggressive play but in the final analysis Ilkeston were lucky to finish with as many as ten men on the field. We have seen a lot of referees who would have dismissed at least two other Ilkeston players and a couple of Whitby players may have even followed them.

 

Once again Ilkeston Town were let down by the bizarre behavour of a minority of their travelling support who reacted very badly to the dismissal of Liam Walshe. Ironically from where we sat in the stand it certainly did look like Liam raised his elbow. Whether the blow was as strong as Dave McTiernan made out only he will be able to answer. 

 

At the end of the day it was only a League Cup tie and what is really important is league points and Ilkeston will have the opportunity on Saturday to secure another triple haul when they entertain Kidsgrove Athletic.

 
Goddard on the run Campbell in the Whitby goal saves Jemson wins a header